BPG is committed to discovery and dissemination of knowledge
Retrospective Study
©Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2026.
World J Gastroenterol. Mar 7, 2026; 32(9): 114200
Published online Mar 7, 2026. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v32.i9.114200
Table 1 Clinicopathological characteristics of patients, n (%)
Characteristics
Training cohort (n = 2496)
Validation cohort (n = 1293)
P value
Sex 0.518
    Male1513 (60.6)769 (59.5)
    Female983 (39.4)524 (40.5)
Age, mean (SD)65.64 (10.14)60.73 (10.33)< 0.001
Height, mean (SD)166.37 (9.16)167.52 (28.99)0.069
Weight, mean (SD)66.58 (12.43)66.25 (11.90)0.432
Smoking< 0.001
    Negative1370 (54.9)889 (68.8)
    Positive1126 (45.1)404 (31.2)
Drinking0.853
    Negative1963 (78.6)1021 (79.0)
    Positive533 (21.4)272 (21.0)
Ileus< 0.001
    Negative2139 (85.7)1181 (91.3)
    Positive357 (14.3)112 (8.7)
Diabetes< 0.001
    Negative2338 (93.7)1159 (89.6)
    Positive158 (6.3)134 (10.4)
Hypertension< 0.001
    Negative2304 (92.3)1013 (78.3)
    Positive192 (7.7)280 (21.7)
Differentiation< 0.001
    Well7 (0.3)173 (13.4)
    Moderate2060 (82.5)1023 (79.1)
    Poor429 (17.2)97 (7.5)
Signet-ring cell carcinoma0.022
    Negative2444 (97.9)1280 (99.0)
    Positive52 (2.1)13 (1.0)
Mucinous carcinoma< 0.001
    Negative2060 (82.5)1132 (87.5)
    Positive436 (17.5)161 (12.5)
Location< 0.001
    Rectum1232 (49.4)797 (61.6)
    Left colon684 (27.4)267 (20.6)
    Right colon580 (23.2)229 (17.7)
Vascular cancer embolus0.051
    Negative2260 (90.5)1196 (92.5)
    Positive236 (9.5)97 (7.5)
Perineural invasion0.397
    Negative2056 (82.4)1080 (83.5)
    Positive440 (17.6)213 (16.5)
Stage< 0.001
    II1285 (51.5)780 (60.3)
    III1211 (48.5)513 (39.7)
Microsatellite stability< 0.001
    MSI-H178 (7.1)30 (2.3)
    MSS804 (32.2)504 (39.0)
    No detection1514 (60.7)759 (58.7)
Recurrence or metastasis site0.002
    No recurrence or metastasis2158 (86.5)1171 (90.6)
    Liver121 (4.8)52 (4.0)
    Lung101 (4.0)32 (2.5)
    Recurrence25 (1.0)14 (1.1)
    Abdominal pelvic and viscera in abdominal pelvic46 (1.8)16 (1.2)
    Others (brain, bone, superficial lymph nodes, etc.)45 (1.8)8 (0.6)
Adjuvant chemotherapy type< 0.001
    Folfox134 (5.4)254 (19.6)
    Xelox981 (39.3)391 (30.2)
    Monotherapy105 (4.2)191 (14.8)
    No adjuvant chemotherapy1276 (51.1)457 (35.3)
Table 2 Univariate and multivariate stepwise Cox regression analysis (stepped by Akaike information criterion) of overall survival in training cohort
VariablesLevelUnivariate analysis
Multivariate analysis

HR
95%CI
P value
HR
95%CI
P value
SexFemale (reference = male)0.96300.8180-1.13000.6550
AgeAge (continuous)1.03001.0200-1.0400< 0.0011.03301.0234-1.0417< 0.001
WeightWeight (continuous)0.99800.9920-1.00000.5340
HeightHeight (continuous)1.00000.9950-1.01000.40101.00720.9987-1.01580.0950
SmokingPositive (reference = negative)1.01000.8620-1.19000.8890
DrinkingPositive (reference = negative)1.14000.9460-1.37000.1690
IleusPositive (reference = negative)1.36001.1100-1.67000.00321.35891.1019-1.67580.0041
DiabetesPositive (reference = negative)1.60001.2200-2.09000.0006
HypertensionPositive (reference = negative)1.21000.9210-1.58000.1730
DifferentiationModerate (reference = well)0.62600.2010-1.95000.41900.61630.1971-1.92660.4052
Poor (reference = well)0.91900.2920-2.89000.88500.80020.2535-2.52600.7039
Signet-ring cell carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)1.85001.1700-2.91000.0086
Mucinous carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)1.23001.0100-1.50000.04171.23691.0115-1.51250.0383
LocationLeft colon (reference = rectum)0.78200.6470-0.94500.01100.77620.6404-0.94070.0098
Right colon (reference = rectum)0.75400.6120-0.92900.00810.77440.6256-0.95860.0189
Perineural invasionPositive (reference = negative)1.87001.560-2.2400< 0.0011.61071.3309-1.9492< 0.001
Vascular cancer embolusPositive (reference = negative)1.87001.4900-2.3400< 0.0011.38681.0981-1.75140.0060
Microsatellite stabilityMSS (reference = MSI-H)1.11000.7610-1.61000.5940
No detection (reference = MSI-H)1.65001.1600-2.36000.0056
AJCC stageStage III (reference = stage II)1.93001.6400-2.2700< 0.0011.69191.4248-2.0090< 0.001
Pre-CEAPre-CEA (continuous)1.00301.0020-1.0040< 0.001
Post-CEAPost-CEA (continuous)1.00101.0010-1.0010< 0.0011.00081.0004-1.0012< 0.001
Pre-CA 19-9Pre-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.000-1.0000.0001
Post-CA19-9Post-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.000-1.000< 0.001
Table 3 Univariate and multivariate stepwise Cox regression analysis (stepped by Akaike information criterion) of disease-free survival in training cohort
VariablesLevelUnivariate analysis
Multivariate analysis

HR
95%CI
P value
HR
95%CI
P value
SexFemale (reference = male)0.95600.8220-1.11000.5560
AgeAge (continuous)1.02001.0100-1.0300< 0.0011.02191.0141-1.0298< 0.001
WeightWeight (continuous)1.00000.9950-1.01000.9010
HeightHeight (continuous)1.01000.9970-1.01000.18101.00871.0004-1.01710.0411
SmokingPositive (reference = negative)0.94900.8190-1.10000.4880
DrinkingPositive (reference = negative)1.18000.9950-1.40000.0564
IleusPositive (reference = negative)1.48001.2300-1.7900< 0.0011.46221.2071-1.77120.0001
DiabetesPositive (reference = negative)1.94001.5300-2.4600< 0.0011.51641.1925-1.92850.0007
HypertensionPositive (reference = negative)1.43001.1300-1.82000.0034
DifferentiationModerate (reference = well)0.75800.2430-2.36000.63200.73950.2368-2.30920.6035
Poor (reference = well)1.10000.3500-3.44000.87400.93630.2974-2.94810.9105
Signet-ring cell carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)1.80001.1700-2.78000.0078
Mucinous carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)1.24001.0300-1.49000.02061.21251.0070-1.45990.0420
LocationLeft colon (reference = rectum)0.80000.6720-0.95200.01220.79830.6689-0.95280.0126
Right colon (reference = rectum)0.78000.6440-0.94400.01070.79790.6553-0.97150.0246
Perineural invasionPositive (reference = negative)1.79001.5100-2.1300< 0.0011.54551.2952-1.8441< 0.001
Vascular cancer embolusPositive (reference = negative)1.67001.3500-2.0700< 0.0011.24150.9940-1.55060.0565
Microsatellite stabilityMSS (reference = MSI-H)1.10000.7800-1.56000.5810
No detection (reference = MSI-H)1.67001.2100-2.32000.0020
AJCC stageStage III (reference = stage II)1.98001.7000-2.3000< 0.0011.72441.4716-2.0205< 0.001
Pre-CEAPre-CEA (continuous)1.00301.0020-1.0040< 0.001
Post-CEAPost-CEA (continuous)1.00101.0010-1.0020< 0.0011.00071.0002-1.00110.0022
Pre-CA 19-9Pre-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.0000-1.0000< 0.0011.00061.0000-1.00130.0578
Post-CA 19-9Post-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.0000-1.0000< 0.001
Table 4 Univariate and multivariate stepwise Cox regression analysis (stepped by Akaike information criterion) analyses of overall survival in validation cohort
VariablesLevelUnivariate analysis
Multivariate analysis
HR
95%CI
P value
HR
95%CI
P value
SexFemale (reference = male)0.97000.7330-1.29000.8340
AgeAge (continuous)1.04001.0200-1.0500< 0.0011.03391.0192-1.0489< 0.001
WeightWeight (continuous)0.99300.9800-1.00000.2410
HeightHeight (continuous)0.97800.9610-0.99600.01910.98280.9649-1.00110.0650
SmokingPositive (reference = negative)0.95800.7070-1.30000.7840
DrinkingPositive (reference = negative)0.72100.4920-1.06000.0946
IleusPositive (reference = negative)1.25000.8420-1.85000.26801.52570.9942-2.34130.0532
DiabetesPositive (reference = negative)1.51001.0200-2.26000.0420
HypertensionPositive (reference = negative)1.43001.0500-1.97000.0256
DifferentiationModerate (reference = well)0.48600.3470-0.6820< 0.0010.54180.3803-0.77200.0007
Poor (reference = well)0.62000.3450-1.11000.11000.80040.4386-1.46080.4683
Signet-ring cell carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)5.25002.4600-11.200< 0.001
Mucinous carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)1.12000.7730-1.61000.55901.06180.7103-1.58730.7699
LocationLeft colon (reference = rectum)0.88500.6230-1.26000.49500.86880.5923-1.27440.4718
Right colon (reference = rectum)1.09000.7730-1.55000.61300.91030.6058-1.36800.6512
Perineural invasionPositive (reference = negative)1.43001.0200-2.02000.04031.13500.7867-1.63760.4982
Vascular cancer embolusPositive (reference = negative)2.56001.7400-3.7500< 0.0011.93041.2780-2.91590.0018
Microsatellite stabilityMSS (reference = MSI-H)0.53200.2400-1.18000.1200
No detection (reference = MSI-H)0.73600.3440-1.57000.4270
AJCC stageStage III (reference = stage II)2.05001.5500-2.7100< 0.0011.76451.3127-2.37170.0002
Pre-CEAPre-CEA (continuous)1.00301.0020-1.0040< 0.001
Post-CEAPost-CEA (continuous)1.00201.001-1.00300.00051.00151.0004-1.00250.0058
Pre-CA 19-9Pre-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.0000-1.0000< 0.001
Post-CA 19-9Post-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.0000-1.0000< 0.001
Table 5 Univariate and multivariate stepwise Cox regression analysis (stepped by Akaike information criterion) of disease-free survival in validation cohort
VariablesLevelUnivariate analysis
Multivariate analysis
HR
95%CI
P value
HR
95%CI
P value
SexFemale (reference = male)1.13000.8830-1.45000.3300
AgeAge (continuous)1.03001.0200-1.0400< 0.0011.02681.0140-1.0398< 0.001
WeightWeight (continuous)0.99100.9800-1.00000.0908
HeightHeight (continuous)0.97700.9610-0.99200.00340.97830.9624-0.99440.0084
SmokingPositive (reference = negative)0.93600.7140-1.23000.6330
DrinkingPositive (reference = negative)0.78400.5630-1.09000.1500
IleusPositive (reference = negative)1.30000.9090-1.86000.15001.55411.0495-2.30140.0277
DiabetesPositive (reference = negative)1.54001.0800-2.20000.01631.37280.9581-1.96720.0842
HypertensionPositive (reference = negative)1.46001.1100-1.94000.0076
DifferentiationModerate (reference = well)0.54300.3990-0.73900.00010.63120.4566-0.87260.0054
Poor (reference = well)0.70200.4190-1.18000.17900.92530.5435-1.57520.7748
Signet-ring cell carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)3.36001.5800-7.12000.0016
Mucinous carcinomaPositive (reference = negative)0.95600.6750-1.35000.8010
LocationLeft colon (reference = rectum)0.93100.6820-1.27000.65500.93430.6638-1.31480.6965
Right colon (reference = rectum)1.01000.7370-1.39000.93500.91490.6299-1.32870.6403
Perineural invasionPositive (reference = negative)1.35000.9910-1.84000.05731.10800.7997-1.53500.5377
Vascular cancer embolusPositive (reference = negative)2.25001.5700-3.2300< 0.0011.81551.2354-2.66790.0024
Microsatellite stabilityMSS (reference = MSI-H)0.61500.2960-1.28000.1930
No detection (reference = MSI-H)0.75500.3710-1.53000.4370
AJCC stageStage III (reference = stage II)1.88001.4600-2.4100< 0.0011.65151.2721-2.14390.0002
Pre-CEAPre-CEA (continuous)1.00301.0010-1.0040< 0.001
Post-CEAPost-CEA (continuous)1.00101.0010-1.00200.00071.00121.0003-1.00220.0100
Pre-CA 19-9Pre-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.0000-1.0000< 0.0011.00141.0005-1.00240.0041
Post-CA 19-9Post-CA 19-9 (continuous)1.00001.0000-1.0000< 0.001
Table 6 Recurrence or metastasis rates in different carcinoembryonic antigen level
Level
Recurrence or metastasis rate in training cohort (%)
Recurrence or metastasis rate in validation cohort (%)
Elevated pre-CEA17.9210.61
Normal pre-CEA10.698.74
Elevated post-CEA27.5819.13
Normal post-CEA11.047.75
Total13.429.36