Meta-Analysis
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2017.
World J Meta-Anal. Dec 26, 2017; 5(6): 167-176
Published online Dec 26, 2017. doi: 10.13105/wjma.v5.i6.167
Table 1 Studies included in meta-analysis
Ref.Type of searchMethod of revascularizationStudy designYearDefinition of CR usedFollow-up (yr)
Bell et al[24]HandPCIPost hoc analysis, non-RCT1990Anatomical2.2
Approach/catherine Mclellan et al[25]HandPCIPost hoc analysis, non-RCT2005Anatomical9
ARTS II/Sarno et al[26]PubMedCABG/PCIPost hoc analysis, non-RCT2010Anatomical5
ARTS trial/van den Brand et al[14]PubMedCABG/PCIPost hoc analysis, RCT2002Anatomical1
SYNTAX trial/Farooq et al[27]PubMedCABG/PCIPost hoc analysis, RCT2013Anatomical4
BARI/Bourassa et al[28]PubMedCABG/PCIPost hoc analysis, RCT1999Anatomical5
Bourassa et al[29]HandPTCAPost hoc analysis, non-RCT1998Anatomical9
Head et al[30]PubMedCABG/PCIPost hoc analysis, RCT2012Anatomical3
BARI 2D/Schwartz et al[31]PubMedCABG/PCIPost hoc analysis, non-RCT2012Numerical5.3
Mohammadi et al[32]HandCABGPost hoc analysis, non-RCT2012Anatomical5.4 ± 3.0
Table 2 Characteristics of patients undergoing complete revascularization
Ref.Prevalence of CR (%)Mean age (yr)Previous MINo previous MIDiabetesNo diabetesHypertensionNo hypertension
Bell et al[24]41.060.012223446319148217
Approach/catherine Mclellan et al[25]66.962.1802506244.61063.4725.94582.06
ARTS II/Sarno et al[26]72.561.5149688163674440397
ARTS trial/van den Brand et al[14]77.261.0385498143.93739.07-
SYNTAX trial/Farooq et al[27]61.865.35211088429.61179.4759.45849.55
BARI/Bourassa et al[28]65.461.3612584204.52991.48578.86617.14
Bourassa et al[29]17.456.6627015.05116.9555.9776.03
Head et al[30]59.964.9328713300438702356
BARI 2D/Schwartz et al[31]37.961.21---
Mohammadi et al[32]82.182.1224167107.92283.08286.21104.79
Table 3 Characteristics of patients undergoing incomplete revascularization
Ref.Prevalence of CR (%)Mean age (yr)Previous MINo previous MIDiabetesNo diabetesHypertensionNo hypertension
Bell et al[24]41.060.012223446319148217
Approach/catherine Mclellan et al[25]66.962.1802506244.61063.4725.94582.06
ARTS II/Sarno et al[26]72.561.5149688163674440397
ARTS trial/van den Brand et al[14]77.261.0385498143.93739.07-
SYNTAX trial/Farooq et al[27]61.865.35211088429.61179.4759.45849.55
BARI/Bourassa et al[28]65.461.3612584204.52991.48578.86617.14
Bourassa et al[29]17.456.6627015.05116.9555.9776.03
Head et al[30]59.964.9328713300438702356
BARI 2D/Schwartz et al[31]37.961.21---
Mohammadi et al[32]82.182.1224167107.92283.08286.21104.79