A cure for type 1 diabetes (T1D) would help millions of people worldwide, but remains elusive thus far. Tolerogenic vaccines and beta cell replacement therapy are complementary therapies that seek to address aberrant T1D autoimmune attack and subsequent beta cell loss. However, both approaches require some form of systematic immunosuppression, imparting risks to the patient. Biomaterials-based tools enable localized and targeted immunomodulation, and biomaterial properties can be designed and combined with immunomodulatory agents to locally instruct specific immune responses. In this Review, we discuss immunomodulatory biomaterial platforms for the development of T1D tolerogenic vaccines and beta cell replacement devices. We investigate nano- and microparticles for the delivery of tolerogenic agents and autoantigens, and as artificial antigen presenting cells, and highlight how bulk biomaterials can be used to provide immune tolerance. We examine biomaterials for drug delivery and as immunoisolation devices for cell therapy and islet transplantation, and explore synergies with other fields for the development of new T1D treatment strategies.

Most islet xenotransplantation laboratories have focused on porcine islets, which are both costly and difficult to isolate. Teleost (bony) fish, such as tilapia, possess macroscopically visible distinct islet organs called Brockmann bodies which can be inexpensively harvested. When transplanted into diabetic nude mice, tilapia islets maintain long-term normoglycemia and provide human-like glucose tolerance profiles. Like porcine islets, when transplanted into euthymic mice, they are rejected in a CD4 T-cell-dependent manner. However, unlike pigs, tilapia are so phylogenetically primitive that their cells do not express α(1,3)Gal and, because tilapia are highly evolved to live in warm stagnant waters nearly devoid of dissolved oxygen, their islet cells are exceedingly resistant to hypoxia, making them ideal for transplantation within encapsulation devices. Encapsulation, especially when combined with co-stimulatory blockade, markedly prolongs tilapia islet xenograft survival in small animal recipients, and a collaborator has shown function in diabetic cynomolgus monkeys. In anticipation of preclinical xenotransplantation studies, we have extensively characterized tilapia islets (morphology, embryologic development, cell biology, peptides, etc.) and their regulation of glucose homeostasis. Because tilapia insulin differs structurally from human insulin by 17 amino acids, we have produced transgenic tilapia whose islets stably express physiological levels of humanized insulin and have now bred these to homozygosity. These transgenic fish can serve as a platform for further development into a cell therapy product for diabetes.

Our goal was to improve islet transplantation as a therapy for patients with type I diabetes mellitus. Because human donor islets are scarce, we are studying islet xenografts in the diabetic NOD mouse model. We hypothesize that optimal xenoislet survival will be achieved by the combination of donor islet immunoisolation with recipient immunosuppression. We and others have studied adult and neonatal porcine islets as sources of tissue for microencapsulated islet xenografts, but we believe it is also advantageous to consider using islets from fish, which can be raised in large numbers relatively quickly and economically. Therefore, in this study, we have evaluated the function of microencapsulated xenogeneic piscine (tilapia) islets transplanted intraperitoneally (IP) in NOD mice in the presence of CD4(+) T-cell depletion and/or costimulatory blockade.

Spontaneously diabetic NOD mice or streptozotocin (STZ)-diabetic NOD-SCID mice were transplanted IP with microencapsulated tilapia islets. Recipient immunosuppression included anti-CD4 mAb, CTLA4-Ig, anti-CD80 mAb, anti-CD86 mAb, or anti-CD154 mAb, alone or in combination. Graft function was evaluated by blood glucose (BG) levels, intravenous (IV) and oral glucose tolerance tests (GTTs), histologic and immunohistochemical analyses of grafts, and flow cytometric analysis of peritoneal cells.

Encapsulated tilapia islets normalized random BG levels for up to 210 days in NOD-SCID mice. In diabetic NOD mice, encapsulated tilapia islets were rejected on day 11 ± 4 with a peritoneal infiltrate of macrophages, eosinophils, B cells, occasional neutrophils, but few T cells. Immunohistochemical staining demonstrated the presence of murine IgG on tilapia islets within capsules of rejecting, non-immunosuppressed mice, as well as murine IgG-positive lymphocytes in the layer of host cells surrounding those capsules. These findings suggested that our barium (Ba)-gelled alginate capsules are permeable to IgG and that anti-piscine antibodies may be involved in the rejection of encapsulated tilapia islets in untreated mice. No single immunosuppressive agent prolonged encapsulated tilapia islet survival in NOD mice, but the combination of CTLA4-Ig plus anti-CD154 mAb extended tilapia islet graft survival until rejection at 119 ± 20 days and inhibited host cell recruitment to the peritoneal cavity. Triple treatment with CTLA4-Ig, anti-CD154 mAb, and anti-CD4 mAb allowed graft survival for 157 ± 35 days with little evidence of a host cellular reaction. IV and oral glucose tolerance tests (GTTs) of recipients with functioning xenografts demonstrated remarkably normal metabolic function.

We conclude that microencapsulated tilapia islets can survive long term with excellent metabolic control in diabetic mice given targeted immunosuppression, suggesting that cross-species physiological incompatibility may not compromise the applicability of this novel approach for future clinical applications. We predict that an improved microcapsule that prevents the entrance of IgG will enhance tilapia islet survival in this model, possibly allowing the application of this technique with limited or no immunosuppression.

In spite of intensive research, the molecular basis of allograft and xenograft rejection still remains not fully understood. The acute rejection of an allograft is associated with the intragraft Th1 cytokine response, while tolerance of an allograft or xenograft rejection is accompanied by a higher production of the Th2 cytokines interleukin (IL)-4 and IL-10. Nevertheless, these cytokines are not the final regulatory and effector molecules mediating transplantation reactions. Data indicate that the functioning of common molecules with enzymatic activities, such are inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), arginase, heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) or indoleamine-2,3-dioxygenase (IDO), the bioavailability of their substrates (L-arginine, tryptophan, heme) and the cytotoxic and regulatory actions of their small gaseous products (NO, CO) can be the ultimate mechanisms responsible for effector or regulatory reactions. Using models of transplantation immunity and tolerance we show that T cell receptor-mediated recognition of allogeneic or xenogeneic antigens as well as the balance between immunity/tolerance induces distinct cytokine production profiles. The ratio between Th1 and Th2 cytokines efficiently regulates the expression of genes for common enzymes, such as iNOS, arginase, HO-1 and IDO. These enzymes may compete for substrates, such as L-arginine or tryptophan, and the final product of their activity are small molecules (NO, CO) displaying effector or regulatory functions of the immune system. Thus, it is suggested that in spite of the high immunological specificity of transplatation reaction, the ultimate players in regulatory and effector functions could be small and common molecules.

Beta cell replacement therapy has been proposed as a novel therapy for the treatment of type 1 diabetes. The proof of concept has been demonstrated with successful islet allotransplantation. Islet xenotransplantation has been proposed as an alternative, more reliable, and infinite source of beta cells. The advantages of islet xenotransplantation are the ability to transplant a well differentiated cell that is responsive to glucose and the potential for genetic modification which focuses the treatment on the donor rather than the recipient. The major hurdle remains overcoming the severe cellular rejection that affects xenografts. This review will focus on the major advances that have occurred with genetic modification and the successful therapeutic strategies that have been demonstrated in nonhuman primates. Novel approaches to overcome cell-mediated rejection including biological agents that target selectively costimulation molecules, the development of local immunosuppression through genetic manipulation, and encapsulation will be discussed. Overall, there has been considerable progress in all these areas, which eventually should lead to clinical trials.

Microencapsulation may allow for immunosuppression-free islet transplantation. Herein we investigated whether human islets can be shipped safely to a remote encapsulation core facility and maintain in vitro and in vivo functionality. In non-encapsulated islets before and encapsulated islets after shipment, viability was 88.3+/-2.5 and 87.5+/-2.7% (n=6, p=0.30). Stimulation index after static glucose incubation was 5.4+/-0.5 and 6.3+/-0.4 (n=6, p=0.18), respectively. After intraperitoneal transplantation, long-term normoglycemia was consistently achieved with 3,000, 5,000, and 10,000 IEQ encapsulated human islets. When transplanting 1,000 IEQ, mice returned to hyperglycemia after 30-55 (n=4/7) and 160 days (n=3/7). Transplanted mice showed human oral glucose tolerance with lower glucose levels than non-diabetic control mice. Capsules retrieved after transplantation were intact, with only minimal overgrowth. This study shows that human islets maintained the viability and in vitro function after encapsulation and the inhomogeneous alginate-Ca(2+)/Ba(2+) microbeads allow for long-term in vivo human islet graft function, despite long-distance shipment.

Type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) is caused by the autoimmune destruction of pancreatic islet beta-cells, which are required for the production of insulin. Islet transplantation has been shown to be an effective treatment option for TIDM; however, the current shortage of human islet donors limits the application of this treatment to patients with brittle T1DM. Xenotransplantation of pig islets is a potential solution to the shortage of human donor islets provided xenograft rejection is prevented. We demonstrated that a short-term administration of a combination of anti-LFA-1 and anti-CD154 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) was highly effective in preventing rejection of neonatal porcine islet (NPI) xenografts in non-autoimmune-prone B6 mice. However, the efficacy of this therapy in preventing rejection of NPI xenografts in autoimmune-prone nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice is not known. Given that the current application of islet transplantation is for the treatment of T1DM, we set out to determine whether a combination of anti-LFA-1 and anti-CD154 mAbs could promote long-term survival of NPI xenografts in NOD mice. Short-term administration of a combination of anti-LFA-1 and anti-CD154 mAbs, which we found highly effective in preventing rejection of NPI xenografts in B6 mice, failed to promote long-term survival of NPI xenografts in NOD mice. However, addition of anti-CD4 mAb to short-term treatment of a combination of anti-LFA-1 and anti-CD154 mAbs resulted in xenograft function in 9/12 animals and long-term graft (>100 days) survival in 2/12 mice. Immunohistochemical analysis of islet grafts from these mice identified numerous insulin-producing beta-cells. Moreover, the anti-porcine antibody as well as autoreactive antibody responses in these mice was reduced similar to those observed in naive nontransplanted mice. These data demonstrate that simultaneous targeting of LFA-1, CD154, and CD4 molecules can be effective in inducing long-term islet xenograft survival and function in autoimmune-prone NOD mice.

Transplantation of islets of Langerhans (islets) is a promising method to treat insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (type I diabetes). However, insulin independence is typically realized for only approximately 30% of transplant recipients, even with sufficient numbers of islets from multiple donors. Innate immunological reactions triggered by blood coagulation play a key role in the loss of islets at the early stage. Here we propose a method to inhibit blood coagulation on the islet surface. A plasminogen activator, urokinase, was immobilized on the islet surface via a poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) derivative that carries alkyl chains and thiol groups. When the PVA derivative was added to an islet suspension, the alkyl side chains spontaneously anchored into the lipid bilayer membranes of islet cells. The surfaces of islets were covered with the PVA derivative. Urokinase modified with maleimide groups could be immobilized onto the islet surface by thiol/maleimide bonding with the layer of PVA derivatives. Urokinase-immobilized islets exhibited fibrinolytic properties, indicating that blood coagulation can be controlled on the islet surface. Urokinase immobilization on islets, which does not impair insulin release, represents a promising method to reduce early graft loss after intraportal islet transplantation.

The immune mechanisms associated with the rejection of microencapsulated neonatal porcine islets (NPI) are not clearly understood. Therefore, in this study we characterized the immune cells and molecules that are involved in this process by examining the microencapsulated NPI xenografts at various time points post-transplantation in B6 mice.

Microencapsulated NPI were transplanted into streptozotocin-induced diabetic immune-competent B6 and immune-deficient B6 rag-/- mice and blood glucose levels were monitored twice a week. Encapsulated NPI were then recovered from B6 mice at various time points post-transplantation to characterize the islets and immune response using immunohistochemical and RT-PCR analyses. To determine which T-cell subpopulation is important for the rejection of encapsulated NPI, B6 rag-/- mice with established microencapsulated NPI xenografts were reconstituted with either CD4(+) or CD8(+) T cells and a return to the diabetic state was noted. For controls, adoptive transfer experiments involved reconstitution of B6 rag-/- mice with established microencapsulated NPI with non-fractionated lymph node cells or non-reconstituted mice.

All B6 recipients of microencapsulated NPI remained diabetic throughout the study while B6 rag-/- recipients achieved normoglycemia and maintained normoglycemia for up to 100 days post-transplantation. Encapsulated NPI recovered from B6 mice at early time points (day 7 and day 14) post-transplantation were surrounded with very few layers of immune cells that increased with time post-transplantation. The extent of cellular overgrowth on the surface of encapsulated NPI has a significant correlation with islet cell death and the presence of CD4(+) T cells, B cells and macrophages. Mouse IgG antibody and complement as well as cytokines [gamma-interferon (IFN-gamma), interleukin10 (IL10)] and chemokines (monocyte chemotactic protein-1 and macrophage inflammatory protein-1alpha and beta) were detected within the microcapsules at several time points post-transplantation suggesting that these molecules can traverse the microcapsule. Mouse anti-porcine IgG antibodies in recipient sera were found to peak at 30 days post-transplantation indicating leakage of porcine xenoantigens. In contrast, microencapsulated NPI recovered from B6 rag-/- mice had no cellular overgrowth on the surface. Complement and cytokines (IL 10 but not IFN-gamma) including chemokines were detected within the microcapsules at several days post-transplantation. We also found that B6 rag-/- mice reconstituted with non-fractionated lymph node cells or CD4(+) T cells but not CD8(+) T cells became diabetic demonstrating that CD4(+) T cells are the necessary T-cell subtype for microencapsulated NPI rejection. In contrast, non-reconstituted B6 rag-/- mice remained normoglycemic for the entire duration of the study.

Our results demonstrate that CD4(+) T cells, B cells and macrophages are the immune cells recruited to and involved in the rejection of encapsulated NPI. Immune molecules secreted by these cells as well as complement can traverse the microcapsule membrane and are responsible for destroying the NPI cells. Treatment regimens which target these molecules may modify the rejection of encapsulated NPI and lead to prolonged islet xenograft survival.

Encapsulation of pancreatic islets in alginate is used to protect against xenogenic rejection in different animal models. In this study, several factors, including differences in alginate composition, the presence or absence of xenogenic islet tissue and a transient immunosuppression, were investigated in a model of bovine islet transplantation in rats. A pure alginate with predominantly guluronic acid (Manugel) and an ultrapure low viscosity guluronic acid alginate (UP-LVG) were used. When microcapsules of Manugel or UP-LVG containing 16,000 bovine islet equivalents were transplanted in diabetic rats, we observed normoglycemia for 8.3+/-0.7 (range 6-12 days) and 7.5+/-0.2 days (range 7-8 days) on average, respectively. To ameliorate immunoprotection of alginate microcapsules we repeated the same experiments using transient immunosuppressive therapy. Low doses of cyclosporin A (CyA) administered for 18 days after implantation increased the time in normoglycemia, which averaged 27+/-3 days (range 8-55 days) in Manugel capsules while in UP-LVG capsules it averaged 18+/-8 days (range 3-39 days). The surface of recovered capsules showed less capsules free of overgrowth in Manugel with respect to UP-LVG alginate. These data were comparable with those observed in empty microcapsules similarly implanted, indicating that the capsular overgrowth was not promoted by the presence of xenogenic islet tissue. In recovered Manugel capsules the percentage of capsules without fibrotic overgrowth was higher than that observed without CyA. The same observation was made in empty capsules. These observations indicate that a combination of a highly purified alginate and short-term immunosuppression prolong islet function in a model of xenotransplantation.