Radiotherapy (RT) is a cornerstone of cancer treatment. Compared with conventional high-dose radiation, low-dose radiation (LDR) causes less damage to normal tissues while potentially modulating immune responses and inhibiting tumor growth. LDR stimulates both innate and adaptive immunity, enhancing the activity of natural killer cells, dendritic cells, and T cells. However, the mechanisms underlying the effects of LDR on the immune system remain unclear.

To explore the history, research hotspots, and emerging trends in immune response to LDR literature over the past two decades.

Publications on immune responses to LDR were retrieved from the Web of Science Core Collection. Bibliometric tools, including CiteSpace and HistCite, were used to identify historical features, active topics, and emerging trends in this field.

Analysis of 1244 publications over the past two decades revealed a significant surge in research on immune responses to LDR, particularly in the last decade. Key journals such as INR J Radiat Biol, Cancers, and Radiat Res published pivotal studies. Citation networks identified key studies by authors like Twyman-Saint Victor C (2015) and Vanpouille-Box C (2017). Keyword analysis revealed hotspots such as ipilimumab, stereotactic body RT, and targeted therapy, possibly identifying future research directions. Temporal variations in keyword clusters and alluvial flow maps illustrate the evolution of research themes over time.

This bibliometric analysis provides valuable insights into the evolution of studies on responses to LDR, highlights research trends, and identifies emerging areas for further investigation.

Radiation-induced pneumonitis and fibrosis represent severe and dose-limiting side effects in the radiotherapy of thorax-associated neoplasms leading to decreased quality of life or - as a consequence of treatment with suboptimal radiation doses - to fatal outcomes by local recurrence or metastatic disease. It is assumed that the initial radiation-induced damage to the resident cells triggers a multifaceted damage-signalling cascade in irradiated normal tissues including a multifactorial secretory program. The resulting pro-inflammatory and pro-angiogenic microenvironment triggers a cascade of events that can lead within weeks to a pronounced lung inflammation (pneumonitis) or after months to excessive deposition of extracellular matrix molecules and tissue scarring (pulmonary fibrosis).The use of preclinical in vivo models of DNA damage-induced pneumopathy in genetically modified mice has helped to substantially advance our understanding of molecular mechanisms and signalling molecules that participate in the pathogenesis of radiation-induced adverse late effects in the lung. Herein, murine models of whole thorax irradiation or hemithorax irradiation nicely reproduce the pathogenesis of the human disease with respect to the time course and the clinical symptoms. Alternatively, treatment with the radiomimetic DNA damaging chemotherapeutic drug Bleomycin (BLM) has frequently been used as a surrogate model of radiation-induced lung disease. The advantage of the BLM model is that the symptoms of pneumonitis and fibrosis develop within 1 month.Here we summarize and discuss published data about the role of danger signalling in the response of the lung tissue to DNA damage and its cross-talk with the innate and adaptive immune systems obtained in preclinical studies using immune-deficient inbred mouse strains and genetically modified mice. Interestingly we observed differences in the role of molecules involved in damage sensing (TOLL-like receptors), damage signalling (MyD88) and immune regulation (cytokines, CD73, lymphocytes) for the pathogenesis and progression of DNA damage-induced pneumopathy between the models of pneumopathy induced by whole thorax irradiation or treatment with the radiomimetic drug BLM. These findings underline the importance to pursue studies in the radiation model(s) if we are to unravel the mechanisms driving radiation-induced adverse late effects.A better understanding of the cross-talk of danger perception and signalling with immune activation and repair mechanisms may allow a modulation of these processes to prevent or treat radiation-induced adverse effects. Vice-versa an improved knowledge of the normal tissue response to injury is also particularly important in view of the increasing interest in combining radiotherapy with immune checkpoint blockade or immunotherapies to avoid exacerbation of radiation-induced normal tissue toxicity.

The coming of age for immunotherapy (IT) as a genuine treatment option for cancer patients through the development of new and effective agents, in particular immune checkpoint inhibitors, has led to a huge renaissance of an old idea, namely to harness the power of the immune system to that of radiation therapy (RT). It is not an overstatement to say that the combination of RT with IT has provided a new conceptual platform that has re-energized the field of radiation oncology as a whole. One only has to look at the immense rise in sessions at professional conferences and in grant applications dealing with this topic to see its emergence as a force, while the number of published reviews on the topic is staggering. At the time of writing, over 97 clinical trials have been registered using checkpoint inhibitors with RT to treat almost 7,000 patients, driven in part by strong competition between pharmaceutical products eager to find their market niche. Yet, for the most part, this enthusiasm is based on relatively limited recent data, and on the clinical success of immune checkpoint inhibitors as single agents. A few preclinical studies on RT-IT combinations have added real value to our understanding of these complex interactions, but many assumptions remain. It seems therefore appropriate to go back in time and pull together what actually has been a long history of investigations into radiation and the immune system (Figure 1) in an effort to provide context for this interesting combination of cancer therapies.

Sodium oleate, oleic acid, linolic acid, and linolenic acid injected into mice in suitable amounts induce a material increase in the resistance against subsequent transplantation of cancer grafts, although they fail to exert so marked an influence on cancer grafts already in place. Sodium palmitate and sodium stearate, on the other hand, do not produce immunity, at least in the amounts employed in the present study.

An operative technique was evolved permitting successful partial hypophysectomy in guinea pigs. Such animals, when immunized to Bacillus typhosus, produced specific agglutinins in the same quantity and at the same rate as unoperated and operation controls immunized at the same time and by the same method. In guinea pigs previously immunized to Bacillus typhosus and hen red blood corpuscles partial hypophysectomy had no effect on the continued production and persistence of typhoid agglutinins, hemagglutinins, and hemolysins. In guinea pigs immunized to Bacillus typhosus both the continued ingestion and the intraperitoneal injection of the whole pituitary gland extract (Burroughs Wellcome) had no effect on the subsepuent agglutinin titers as compared to that of normal animals. The experiments would appear to show either that the hypophysis does not play an important direct or indirect part in the production of and persistence in the blood of typhoid agglutinins, hemagglutinins, and hemolysins, or that the amount of hypophysis left behind in the operation in order to maintain life is adequate also to exercise the degree of functional influence on these processes which the entire hypophysis conceivably exercises.

These experiments were designed to look at the cellular effects in key organs in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) after exposure in vivo to radiation and subtoxic levels of aluminum (Al) and cadmium (Cd), alone or in combination. Salmon (25g) were exposed to a single 0.5Gy dose of gamma-irradiation in water containing Cd, Al or Cd+Al. Three fish per group were sacrificed after 1h and the liver, pronephros, fin and gill of each was dissected. Small explants of each tissue were set up. After 2 days, the culture medium was harvested and filtered then placed on a reporter cell line for determination of stress signal activity (bystander effects). Radiation in combination with Cd and/or Al, caused bystander effects in tissues harvested from in vivo exposed salmon. The effects vary between different organs and are not consistently additive or synergistic for a given treatment. Tissue type appears to be critical. Liver cultures produce a toxic factor which is lethal to reporter cells, and therefore no liver data could be obtained. It is hoped that this stress signal response will prove to be a useful indicator of environmental stress in species inhabiting aquatic ecosystems.

Gastric carcinomas are invariably accompanied by lymphoid proliferations. We studied their features in 22 resected gastric carcinomas in which the lymphoid proliferations ranged from reactive lymphoid follicles to mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) lymphomas. In most cases, the collections of lymphocytes were abundant, which is remarkable considering the lack of lymphoid tissue in the normal stomach. They were not haphazardly located but in direct contact with the metaplastic, dysplastic, and neoplastic epithelial cells, in positions suggestive of defense barriers. They consisted of newly formed lymphoid follicles with reactive germinal centers sometimes high up in the superficial mucosa, collections of plasma cells beneath the surface epithelium, and large aggregates of B cells above and below the muscularis mucosae as well as abundant T cells. The latter, both CD4+ and CD8+, were seen within metaplastic epithelial cells as well as within carcinomatous glands that were partially destroyed, resembling apparent neoplastic lympho-epithelial lesions (LEL). In three cases, the B cells infiltrating the gastric muscular layers represented MALT-lymphomas adjacent to gastric carcinomas, as confirmed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis in two cases. In a case of lymphoepithelioma-like carcinoma, the excessive lymphoid cells were predominantly of T-CD8+ type. In this case, EBV identified by EBV-encoded RNA and latent membrane protein was present in large amounts. Helicobacter pylori was seen in only six cases in areas of chronic gastritis that were distant from carcinoma. H. pylori was not present in the areas of metaplasia, dysplasia, or carcinoma. It appears that the lymphoid proliferations accompanying these gastric changes do not arise in response to the pathogenic agent H. pylori, which caused the persistent infection leading to them yet is no longer present, but rather in response to the existence of the abnormal epithelial cells. Thus the lymphoid proliferations consistently associated with gastric metaplasia, dysplasia, and neoplasia may be regarded as immune reactions to the long-term cellular changes triggered by the initial chronic gastritis. On rare occasions, the exaggerated lymphoid proliferations may reach the end of the spectrum, resulting in MALT lymphomas coexistent with gastric carcinomas.

The local immune response to lung cancer was investigated by histologic and immunologic means. Distinctive patterns of stromal cellular reaction, characteristic for different histologic types of lung carcinoma, were recognized. The amount of cellular infiltration was highest in squamous cell carcinomas and lowest or nonexistent in oat cell carcinomas. Within the various histologic categories the well-differentiated tumors appeared to be accompanied by more reactive cells than the poorly differentiated ones; there was no relation between tumor necrosis and cellular infiltration. The plasma cells were distinctly associated with squamous cell carcinomas; their number in the stroma was proportionate to the degree of differentiation and the presence of keratin produced by the tumors. Eluates with a high content of immunoglobulins were recovered from pleural effusions and from solid lung carcinomas by dissociation of antigen-antibody complexes. These preparations reacted positively in indirect immunofluorescence tests with tissue cultures and with fresh suspensions of lung carcinoma cells, but not with tissue culture cells of most nonpulmonary tumors or with cell suspensions of normal adult and fetal lung. Similarly prepared fractions of noncarcinomatous pleural effusions did not react with lung cancer cells.