Gjeorgjievski M, Cappell MS. Portal hypertensive gastropathy: A systematic review of the pathophysiology, clinical presentation, natural history and therapy. World J Hepatol 2016; 8(4): 231-262 [PMID: 26855694 DOI: 10.4254/wjh.v8.i4.231]
Corresponding Author of This Article
Mitchell S Cappell, MD, PhD, Chief, Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, William Beaumont Hospital, MOB #602, 3535 West Thirteen Mile Road, Royal Oak, MI 48073, United States. mscappell@yahoo.com
Research Domain of This Article
Gastroenterology & Hepatology
Article-Type of This Article
Systematic Reviews
Open-Access Policy of This Article
This article is an open-access article which was selected by an in-house editor and fully peer-reviewed by external reviewers. It is distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/
77 patients with bleeding from EV underwent variceal ligation and were randomized to receive propranolol (37/77) or control (40/77); patients with severe PHG prior to treatment excluded from the study
Prospective, randomized, controlled trial
Control group: 7/40 (17%); propranolol group: 8/37 (22%)
At variceal ligation: Control group: 67% (does not state number); Propranolol group: 31% (number not stated); 6 mo after treatment: Control group: 85% (number not stated) propranolol group: 48% (number not stated)
Pre vs post ligation, both groups; P < 0.05; frequency of PHG significantly higher in control group post ligation when compared to propranolol group; P = 0.002
93 patients with history of variceal hemorrhage and cirrhosis, randomized to receive either EVS (46/88) or EVL (42/88); 5 patients excluded due to diagnosis of hepatoma, non-cirrhotic portal hypertension or portal vein thrombosis
Randomized, prospective study
Not reported
PHG significantly worsened in 23 patients, including 17 patients undergoing EVL
P < 0.01
Table 4 Effects of variceal sclerotherapy on frequency of portal hypertensive gastropathy
Pre EVS group: 6 none/24 mild/14 severe; pre EVL group: 4 none/33 mild/9 severe; total: 10 none/57 mild/23 severe
At eradication: 14/29 (48.3%) in EVS; 17/37 (45.9%) in EVL; at 3 mo: 15/26 (57.7%) in EVS; 17/30 (56.7%) in EVL; at 6 mo 15/25 (60%) in EVS; 18/29 (62.1%) in EVL
Non-significant difference in PHG aggravation between EVS and EVL; P > 0.05
186 children with extrahepatic portal vein obstruction presenting with variceal bleeding undergoing endoscopic sclerotherapy, and mean follow up of 38 ± 30 mo
Retrospective study
PHG: 46/186 (24.7%), severe PHG: 6/186 (3.2%)
PHG: 96/186 (51.6%), severe PHG: 29/186 (15.6%)
P < 0.001 for overall PHG; P < 0.05 for severe PHG
967 patients with variceal bleeding underwent endoscopic sclerotherapy; out of whom 88 patients fulfilled the inclusion criteria (including presence of endoscopic lesions consistent with PHG or GAVE, before or within 4 wk after obliteration) were prospectively followed (out of whom 2 had only GAVE)
Prospective study
22 patients had PHG prior to EVS; 2/22 transient (9%); 17/22 persistent (77%); 3/22 progressive (14%)
Additional development in 64 patients post procedure, 28/64 transient (44%), 31/64 persistent (48%), 5/64 progressive (8%)
Only statistically significant difference was the transient PHG that disappeared in 28 (44%) of patients in the group that developed PHG post procedure; P < 0.05
93 patients with history of variceal hemorrhage and cirrhosis, randomized to receive either EVS (46/88) or EVL (42/88); 5 patients were excluded due to diagnosis of hematoma, non-cirrhotic portal hypertension or portal vein thrombosis
Prospective study
Not reported
PHG worsened in 23 patients total; statistically significantly more in EVL group than EVS group (17 vs 6 patients respectively)
212 cirrhotic patients of which 75 had an episode of variceal bleeding and were treated with sclerotherapy; 137 without bleeding were not treated with sclerotherapy
Prospective study
No EVS group at admission: 104/137 (75%) none; 28/137 (20%) mild; 5/137 (4%) severe; EVS group at admission: 50/75 (66%) none; 17/75 (22%) mild; 8/75 (11%) severe
No EVS group at end of study 69/137 (50%) none; 61/137 (45%) mild; 7/137 (5%) severe; EVS group at end of study: 13/75 (17%) none; 49/75 (65%) mild; 13/75 (17%) severe
The conclusion was that sclerotherapy is a significant indicator of the risk of PHG in a multivariate analysis (P = 0.00032)
Table 5 Well-established, important risk factors for portal hypertensive gastropathy
Parameters
Ref.
Portal hypertension
Non-cirrhotic portal hypertension
[8,14]
Cirrhotic portal hypertension
[8,9,34]
Cirrhosis
Longer duration of cirrhosis
[34,71]
Greater severity of cirrhosis
[55,67]
Greater size of esophageal varices
[34,62]
Eradication of esophageal varices
Endoscopic therapies
Endoscopic variceal ligation
[11,41]
Endoscopic sclerotherapy
[11,83]
Angiographic
Percutaneous transhepatic variceal embolization
[85]
Table 6 Therapies affecting the severity or the risk of bleeding from portal hypertensive gastropathy
Therapies reducing severity of PHG
Ref.
TIPS
[76,77,98]
Transcatheter splenic arterial embolization
[99]
Surgical shunt
Portocaval shunt
[100]
Central splenorenal shunt
[101]
Laparoscopic splenectomy (in patients with hypersplenism)
[55]
Liver transplantation
[44]
Therapies reducing risk of bleeding from PHG
TIPS
[75,98,102]
Surgical shunt (portocaval or splenorenal)
[100,101]
Nonselective b β-adrenergic receptor antagonists (e.g., propranolol)
[103 (in rats),104]
Somatostatin family of drugs
Somatostatin
[105]
Octreotide
[106]
Vasopressin family of drugs
Vasopressin
[106]
Terlipressin
[107]
Therapies that increase incidence or risk of bleeding from PHG
Endoscopic therapies for varices
Variceal ligation
[11,41]
Variceal sclerotherapy
[11,83]
Interventional angiography
Percutaneous transhepatic variceal embolization
[85]
Table 7 Factors not affecting risk of portal hypertensive gastropathy
Factors not affecting risk of portal hypertensive gastropathy
Ref.
Etiology of cirrhosis
[8,28,30]
Etiology of non-cirrhotic portal hypertension
[8,14,35,83,108]
Alcoholism
[30,42]
NSAID use
[42]
Use of COX-2 inhibitors
[42]
Smoking tobacco
[42]
Gastric infection with Helicobacter pylori
[109,110]
Table 8 Different classification systems for portal hypertensive gastropathy
Mildly more common in males (alcoholic cirrhosis more common in males than females)
Much more common in females (80%)
[193,194]
Age
Can occur at any age in patients with portal hypertension or cirrhosis
Typically elderly (average age > 70 years old)
Location
Proximal stomach: Fundus, body
Distal stomach: Antrum
[72,192]
Diagnosis
Endoscopy (endoscopic biopsy sometimes useful). Radiologic imaging usually not helpful
Endoscopy (endoscopic biopsy sometimes useful)
[72,195]
Appearance at endoscopy
Mosaic/snakeskin mucosa with red or brown spots
Tortuous columns of ectatic vessels in "watermelon" or diffuse pattern; erythematous or hemorrhagic
[191]
Histology
Ectatic capillaries, mildly dilated mucosal and submucosal veins; no vascular inflammation, no vascular thrombi
Marked dilation of capillaries and venules in gastric mucosa and submucosa with areas of intimal thickening, fibrin thrombi, fibromuscular hyperplasia and spindle cell proliferation
[72,191,196,197]
Clinical presentation/ complications
Gastrointestinal bleeding: Usually chronic, but sometimes acute
Almost exclusively chronic gastrointestinal bleeding with guaiac positive stools
[37,193]
Primary prophylaxis
Not indicated
Not indicated (unless associated with large varices)
Oral contraceptive pills to temporarily control bleeding
Questionable benefit of octreotide
Endoscopic therapy
Occasionally helpful (for focal bleeding)
Very helpful at reducing risk of bleeding: Argon plasma coagulation; EBL; Radiofrequency ablation; YAG laser therapy
[202-207]
Argon plasma coagulation
Local hemostasis with hemospray
TIPS
Significantly reduces severity and risk of bleeding by reducing portal hypertension. Option for very severe bleeding from PHG or for moderate PHG in patients with variceal bleeding
Not recommended. Does not affect severity of GAVE or risk of bleeding
[75,77]
Liver transplantation
Resolves. Ultimate therapy mostly reserved for patients with end-stage liver disease
Improves or resolves with liver transplantation
[75,200,208-210]
Other surgery
Usually resolves with shunt surgery that lowers portal pressure. Partial gastrectomy not recommended
Limited surgical resection (partial gastrectomy) recommended for refractory cases. Shunt surgery not recommended
[75,200,211-213]
Prognosis from bleeding
Bleeding rarely severe and very rarely fatal
Bleeding occasionally severe
[34,71,72]
Table 10 Differences in gastrointestinal bleeding from portal hypertensive gastropathy vs esophageal varices
Parameter
Portal hypertensive gastropathy
Esophageal varices
Etiology
Portal hypertension: Cirrhotic or non-cirrhotic
Portal hypertension: Cirrhotic or non-cirrhotic
Concurrence
Frequently occur simultaneously with esophageal varices because the two diseases share common risk factors
Frequently occurs simultaneously with PHG because the two diseases have common risk factors
Location
Stomach: Predominantly fundus and body
Distal esophagus: Also can have gastric varices or ectopic varices in other gastrointestinal regions, particularly duodenum
Diagnosis
Esophagogastroduodenoscopy
Esophagogastroduodenoscopy
Endoscopic appearance
Erythematous small polygonal areas of mucosa surrounded by a fine, whitish, reticular or mosaic/snakeskin mucosa with red or brown spots
Serpiginous mucosal greyish luminal projections in distal esophagus
Clinical presentation
Mild acute or chronic bleeding
Acute gastrointestinal bleeding-typically massive
Severity of bleeding
Typically mild and not life-threatening
Typically severe and life-threatening
Histology
Not biopsied at endoscopy
Endoscopic therapy
Limited role
Variceal ligation recommended as initial therapy. Sclerotherapy an alternative therapy
Medical therapy
Octreotide
Octreotide
Propranolol
Propranolol
Vasopressin or vasopressin analogues-infrequently recommended any more
Vasopressin or vasopressin analogues-infrequently recommended any more
Blakemore tube
Not recommended
Sometimes used for refractory bleeding especially as a temporizing measure before performing more definitive therapy
Angiographic therapy
TIPS used as a last resort
TIPS recommended if endoscopic therapy fails
Transfusion of packed erythrocytes
Transfuse only to hematocrit of about 28. Over-transfusion may increase portal pressure and induce greater bleeding
Transfuse only to hematocrit of about 28. Over-transfusion may increase portal pressure and induce greater bleeding
Liver transplantation
Improves or resolves with liver transplantation
Improves or resolves with liver transplantation
Prognosis
Rarely fatal
Frequently fatal
Table 11 Rates of gastrointestinal bleeding from portal hypertensive gastropathy
127 patients with portal hypertension of various etiologies
29 patients out of 65 with PHG, representing 25% of the total number of bleeds from all sources; 9 episodes presenting with bleeding; 71 episodes of subsequent bleeding
297 patients with living donor liver transplantation; retrospective analysis
2 patients bled from PHG within 3 mo after transplantation
Table 12 Treatment of acute or chronic gastrointestinal bleeding from portal hypertensive gastropathy
Acute bleeding
Patient stabilization
Treat severe coagulopathy with highly elevated INR associated with cirrhosis with fresh frozen plasma
Treat severe thrombocytopenia associated with hypersplenism and bone marrow suppression from alcoholism with platelet transfusions
Transfuse packed erythrocytes to main hemoglobin level at about 8 g/dL
Consider antibiotic prophylaxis in patient with cirrhosis
Endoscopic therapy from bleeding-rarely used
Consider argon plasma coagulation
Hemospray - an experimental therapy
Pharmacotherapy
Octreotide - first line therapy
Vasopressin or terlipressin - second line therapy
Proton pump inhibitor therapy - adjunct therapy
Propranolol - can be instituted after bleeding controlled and patient stabilized
Interventional therapy
TIPS - for uncontrolled hemorrhage or for bleeding from PHG associated with variceal bleeding
Liver transplantation - for advanced end stage liver disease
Chronic bleeding
Treatment of anemia
Transfusions of packed erythrocytes as necessary
Iron replacement therapy
Pharmacotherapy
Consider propranolol
Citation: Gjeorgjievski M, Cappell MS. Portal hypertensive gastropathy: A systematic review of the pathophysiology, clinical presentation, natural history and therapy. World J Hepatol 2016; 8(4): 231-262