Retrospective Study
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2025.
World J Gastroenterol. Aug 14, 2025; 31(30): 109863
Published online Aug 14, 2025. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v31.i30.109863
Table 1 Baseline characteristics of triglyceride-glucose index < 1.58 and triglyceride-glucose index ≥ 1.58, mean ± SD/n (%)
Variables
Overall (N = 278), mean ± SD (%)
Low TyG index (n = 134)
High TyG index (n = 144)
P value
BMI, kg/m222.67 ± 2.8921.86 ± 2.6823.53 ± 2.87< 0.001a
Fasting glucose, mg/dL5.47 ± 1.244.83 ± 0.806.56 ± 1.10< 0.001a
Fasting triglycerides, mg/dL1.73 ± 0.421.42 ± 0.272.07 ± 0.25< 0.001a
Tyg index1.66 ± 0.561.24 ± 0.432.12 ± 0.23< 0.001a
Age, years0.673
< 60125 (44.96)62 (46.27)63 (43.75)
≥ 60153 (55.04)72 (53.73)81 (56.25)
Sex0.637
Female141 (50.72)66 (49.25)75 (52.08)
Male137 (49.28)68 (50.75)69 (47.92)
Drinking history0.428
No191 (68.71)89 (66.42)102 (70.83)
Yes87 (31.29)45 (33.58)42 (29.17)
Smoking history0.887
No192 (69.06)92 (68.66)100 (69.44)
Yes86 (30.94)42 (31.34)44 (30.56)
ECOG0.183
0182 (65.47)93 (69.40)89 (61.81)
196 (34.53)41 (30.60)55 (38.19)
Hypertensive0.545
No169 (60.79)79 (58.96)90 (62.50)
Yes109 (39.21)55 (41.04)54 (37.50)
Diabetes0.132
No210 (75.54)112 (83.58)98 (68.06)
Yes68 (24.46)22 (16.42)46 (31.94)
HBV DNA (IU/mL)0.216
HBV ≤ 2000147 (52.88)76 (56.72)71 (49.31)
HBV > 2000131 (47.12)58 (43.28)73 (50.69)
AFP, ng/mL0.431
< 1210126 (45.38)64 (47.76)62 (43.06)
≥ 1210152 (54.68)70 (52.24)82 (56.94)
HBe0.328
Negative202 (72.66)101 (75.37)101 (70.14)
Positive76 (27.34)33 (24.63)43 (29.86)
Metastasis0.178
No190 (68.35)94 (70.15)96 (66.67)
Yes88 (31.65)40 (29.85)48 (33.33)
Child-Pugh class0.241
A158 (56.83)81 (60.45)77 (53.47)
B120 (43.17)53 (39.55)67 (46.53)
BCLC stage0.830
B145 (52.16)69 (51.49)76 (54.17)
C133 (47.84)65 (48.51)68 (45.83)
PVTT0.215
No212 (76.26)104 (77.71)108 (75.00)
Yes66 (23.74)30 (22.29)36 (25.00)
ALT (U/L)0.683
≤ 40150 (53.96)74 (47.76)76 (52.78)
> 40128 (46.04)60 (52.24)68 (47.22)
Total bilirubin (μmol/L)0.182
> 34173 (62.23)78 (58.21)95 (65.97)
≤ 34105 (37.77)56 (41.79)49 (34.03)
Cirrhosis0.213
No149 (53.60)77 (57.46)72 (50.00)
Yes129 (46.40)57 (42.54)72 (50.00)
Interventional0.845
No156 (56.12)76 (56.72)80 (55.56)
Yes122 (43.88)58 (43.28)64 (44.44)
Table 2 Tumor responses of triglyceride-glucose index < 1.58 and triglyceride-glucose index ≥ 1.58, n (%)
Variables
Low TyG index (n = 134)
High TyG index (n = 144)
χ2
P value
CR
0133 (99.25)144 (100.00)
11 (0.75)0 (0.00)
PR
0105 (78.36)126 (87.50)
129 (21.64)18 (12.50)
SD
078 (58.21)88 (61.11)
156 (41.79)56 (38.89)
PD
086 (64.18)74 (51.39)
148 (35.82)70 (48.61)
ORR4.750.029a
0104 (77.61)126 (87.50)
130 (22.39)18 (12.50)
DCR4.650.031a
048 (35.82)70 (48.61)
186 (64.18)74 (51.39)
Table 3 Univariate and multivariate analyses of prognostic factors for progression-free survival
FactorsUnivariate
Multivariate
HR (95%CI)
P value
HR (95%CI)
P value
AFP (≤ 1210 vs > 1210), ng/mL2.22 (1.50-3.29)< 0.001a1.73 (1.15-2.62)0.009a
Age (< 60 vs ≥ 60), years1.03 (0.71-1.50)0.881--
ALT (≤ 40 vs > 40), U/L1.08 (0.74-1.56)0.705--
BCLC stage (B vs C)2.35 (1.60-3.46)< 0.001a1.97 (1.32-2.94)< 0.001a
BMI (< 25 vs ≥ 25), kg/m20.51 (0.29-0.89)< 0.001a0.55 (0.37-0.83)0.037a
Child-Pugh score (C vs B)0.94 (0.65-1.37)0.757--
Diabetes (no vs yes)1.05 (0.63-1.73)0.861--
Cirrhosis (yes vs no)0.82 (0.56-1.20)0.308--
ECOG (0-1 vs 2)2.07 (1.40-3.08)< 0.001a1.68 (1.11-2.53)0.014a
HBe (positive vs negative)0.89 (0.59-1.35)0.587--
HBV-DNA (HBV ≤ 2000 vs HBV > 2000), IU/mL1.05 (0.72-1.52)0.802--
Hypertensive (no vs yes)1.06 (0.72-1.56)0.777--
PVTT (no vs yes)1.27 (0.88-1.85)0.203--
Metastasis (no vs yes)1.88 (1.28-2.74)0.001a1.66 (1.13-2.45)0.010a
Sex (male vs female)1.08 (0.74-1.56)0.697--
TyG index (high vs low)0.45 (0.30-0.67)< 0.001a0.55 (0.37-0.83)0.005a
Total bilirubin (> 34 vs ≤ 34), μmol/L0.98 (0.67-1.45)0.993--
Interventional (no vs yes)1.03 (0.71-1.50)0.875--
Table 4 Univariate and multivariate analyses of prognostic factors for overall survival
FactorsUnivariate
Multivariate
HR (95%CI)
P value
HR (95%CI)
P value
AFP (≤ 1210 vs > 1210), ng/mL2.15 (1.44-3.21)< 0.001a1.51 (1.01-2.28)0.046a
Age (< 60 vs ≥ 60), years1.14 (0.78-1.67)0.507--
ALT (≤ 40 vs > 40), U/L1.11 (0.76-1.62)0.575--
BCLC stage (B vs C)2.40 (1.62-3.53)< 0.001a1.87 (1.25-2.80)0.002a
BMI (< 25 vs ≥ 25), kg/ m20.72 (0.44-1.19)0.202--
Child-Pugh score (B vs C)1.02 (0.70-1.49)0.906--
Diabetes (yes vs no)0.94 (0.56-1.58)0.820--
Cirrhosis (no vs yes)1.29 (0.88-1.88)0.189--
ECOG (0-1 vs 2)2.28 (1.52-3.42)< 0.001a1.71 (1.12-2.61)0.012a
HBe (negative vs positive)1.20 (0.81-1.79)0.364--
HBV-DNA (HBV ≤ 2000 vs HBV > 2000), IU/mL1.01 (0.69-1.48)0.954--
Hypertensive (yes vs no)0.97 (0.65-1.45)0.887--
PVTT (no vs yes)1.37 (0.94-2.00)0.101--
Metastasis (no vs yes)1.78 (1.21-2.62)0.003a1.58 (1.07-2.33)0.021a
Sex (male vs female)1.05 (0.72-1.53)0.794--
TyG index (high vs low)0.37 (0.25-0.56)< 0.001a0.48 (0.31-0.72)< 0.001a
Total bilirubin (≤ 34 vs > 34), μmol/L1.23 (0.84-1.81)0.286--
Interventional (no vs yes)1.09 (0.75-1.58)0.666--
Table 5 Comparison of features between the training and validation sets, n (%)
Characteristic
Test (n = 84)
Train (n = 194)
χ2
P value
Age, years0.100.747
< 6039 (46.43)86 (44.33)
≥ 6045 (53.57)108 (55.67)
Sex0.790.375
Female46 (54.76)95 (48.97)
Male38 (45.24)99 (51.03)
BMI, kg/m20.810.369
< 2564 (76.19)157 (80.39)
≥ 2520 (23.81)37 (19.07)
TyG index0.020.894
Low41 (48.81)93 (47.94)
High43 (51.19)101 (47.94)
HBV-DNA0.800.371
HBV ≤ 200041 (48.81)106 (54.64)
HBV > 200043 (51.19)88 (45.36)
HBe0.080.778
Negative62 (73.81)140 (72.16)
Positive22 (26.19)54 (27.84)
ECOG0.070.785
0-154 (64.29)128 (65.98)
230 (35.71)85 (34.02)
Child-Pugh score0.000.961
B44 (52.38)101 (56.19)
C40 (47.62)93 (43.81)
PVTT1.550.213
No60 (71.43)152 (78.35)
Yes24 (28.57)42 (21.65)
Diabetes2.410.121
No59 (70.24)153 (83.15)
Yes25 (29.76)41 (16.85)
AFP, ng/mL0.650.420
< 121035 (41.67)91 (46.91)
≥ 121049 (58.33)103 (53.09)
BCLC class1.580.208
B39 (46.43)106 (54.64)
C45 (53.57)88 (45.36)
Metastasis1.660.197
No62 (73.81)128 (65.98)
Yes22 (26.19)66 (34.02)
ALT0.760.384
≤ 4042 (50.00)108 (55.67)
> 4042 (50.00)86 (44.33)
Total bilirubin0.220.642
≤ 3454 (64.29)119 (61.34)
> 3430 (35.71)75 (38.66)
Cirrhosis0.070.798
No46 (54.76)103 (53.09)
Yes38 (45.24)91 (46.91)
Interventional0.570.451
No50 (59.52)106 (54.64)
Yes34 (40.48)88 (45.36)
Hypertensive0.130.720
No46 (54.76)123 (63.40)
Yes38 (45.24)50 (36.60)
Table 6 Treatment-related adverse events in patients with hepatocellular camrelizumab, n (%)
Variables
Low TyG index (n = 134)
High TyG index (n = 144)
χ2
P value
All grades: Rash51 (38.06)62 (43.06)0.720.397
All grades: Nausea44 (32.84)53 (36.81)0.480.488
All grades: Fatigue44 (32.84)50 (34.72)0.110.740
All grades: Diarrhea42 (31.34)47 (32.64)0.050.817
All grades: Hypertension15 (11.19)32 (22.22)6.010.014a
All grades: RCCEP14 (10.45)16 (11.11)0.030.859
All grades: Hypothyroidism18 (13.43)15 (10.42)0.600.437
All grades: Elevated ALT12 (8.96)15 (10.42)0.170.681
All grades: Elevated AST12 (8.96)17 (11.81)0.600.437
All grades: Thrombocytopenia10 (7.46)12 (8.33)0.070.788
All grades: Leukopenia20 (14.93)19 (13.19)0.170.678
All grades: Neutropenia17 (12.69)15 (10.42)0.350.554
All grades: Proteinuria8 (5.97)10 (6.94)0.110.742
All grades: Pneumonitis8 (5.97)5 (3.47)0.970.324
All grades: Myocarditis5 (3.73)7 (4.86)0.210.643
≥ 3 grades: Rash22 (16.41)26 (18.06)0.130.718
≥ 3 grades: Nausea14 (10.45)21 (14.58)1.080.299
≥ 3 grades: Fatigue15 (11.19)18 (12.50)0.110.737
≥ 3 grades: Diarrhea10 (7.46)13 (9.03)0.220.636
≥ 3 grades: Hypertension5 (3.73)13 (9.03)3.220.073
≥ 3 grades: RCCEP2 (1.49)3 (2.08)0.010.935
≥ 3 grades: Hypothyroidism5 (3.73)4 (2.78)0.010.912
≥ 3 grades: Elevated ALT4 (2.99)6 (4.17)0.040.837
≥ 3 grades: Elevated AST3 (2.24)6 (4.17)0.320.570
≥ 3 grades: Proteinuria2 (1.49)2 (1.39)0.190.666
≥ 3 grades: Leukopenia6 (4.48)8 (5.56)0.170.681
≥ 3 grades: Neutropenia5 (3.73)4 (2.78)0.010.912
≥ 3 grades: Myocarditis0 (0.00)2 (1.39)0.430.499
≥ 3 grades: Pneumonitis0 (0.00)0 (0.00)--
≥ 3 grades: Thrombocytopenia0 (0.00)0 (0.00)--