Randomized Controlled Trial
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2018.
World J Gastroenterol. Apr 14, 2018; 24(14): 1550-1561
Published online Apr 14, 2018. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v24.i14.1550
Table 1 Demographic and other baseline characteristics in the randomized set (n = 607)1
CharacteristicLPZ 15 mg (n = 201)VPZ 10 mg (n = 202)VPZ 20 mg (n = 204)
Age, yr57.8 ± 12.955.5 ± 13.856.8 ± 13.6
Gender, male140 (69.7)160 (79.2)160 (78.4)
Height, cm163.5 ± 10.2165.5 ± 9.3165.6 ± 9.3
Weight, kg67.0 ± 13.468.2 ± 12.369.0 ± 13.1
Erosive esophagitis grade, investigator-assessed
LA Grade A/B160 (79.6)162 (80.2)161 (78.9)
LA Grade C/D41 (20.4)40 (19.8)43 (21.1)
Esophageal hiatal hernia
≥ 2 cm31 (15.4)45 (22.3)46 (22.5)
< 2 cm105 (52.2)100 (49.5)113 (55.4)
None65 (32.3)57 (28.2)44 (21.6)
H. pylori infection status
Positive29 (14.4)37 (18.3)23 (11.3)
Negative172 (85.6)165 (81.7)181 (88.7)
CYP2C19 genotype
Extensive metabolizers162 (80.6)169 (84.1)169 (83.3)
Poor metabolizers39 (19.4)32 (15.9)34 (16.7)
Table 2 Recurrence rate of erosive esophagitis: Intergroup differences and non-inferiority test
EndpointLPZ 15 mgVPZ 10 mgVPZ 20 mg
Week 24 (primary endpoint)116.8% (33/196)5.1% (10/197)2.0% (4/201)
Week 12 (secondary endpoint)112.2% (24/196)2.5% (5/197)1.0% (2/201)
ComparisonDifference and 95%CI (%)Non-inferiority, P valueFisher exact test, P value2
Week 24 (primary endpoint)
VPZ 10 mg vs LPZ 15 mg-11.8 [-17.83, -5.69]< 0.00010.0002
VPZ 20 mg vs LPZ 15 mg-14.8 [-20.43, -9.26]< 0.0001< 0.0001
VPZ 10 mg vs VPZ 20 mg-3.1 [-6.71, 0.54]N/A0.1090
Week 12 (secondary endpoint)
VPZ 10 mg vs LPZ 15 mg-9.7 [-14.80, -4.62]< 0.0001N/A
VPZ 20 mg vs LPZ 15 mg-11.2 [-16.04, -6.46]< 0.0001N/A
VPZ 10 mg vs VPZ 20 mg-1.5 [-4.13, 1.05]N/AN/A
Table 3 Recurrence rate of erosive esophagitis within 24 wk: sub-group analysis according to baseline characteristics
LPZ 15 mg
VPZ 10 mg
VPZ 20 mg
Estimate (%)1Estimate (%)1Difference2 and 95%CI (%)Fisher exact test, P value3Estimate (%)1Difference2 and 95%CI (%)Fisher exact test, P value3
Age (yr)
< 6514.4 (19/132)4.3 (6/139)-10.1 [-16.95, -3.20]0.00560.0 (0/136)-14.4 [-20.38, -8.41]< 0.0001
≥ 65 to < 7521.7 (10/46)7.0 (3/43)-14.8 [-28.91, -0.62]0.07117.0 (3/43)-14.8 [-28.91, -0.62]0.0711
≥ 7522.2 (4/18)6.7 (1/15)-15.6 [-38.54, 7.43]0.34574.5 (1/22)-17.7 [-38.76, 3.41]0.1554
Sex
Male13.9 (19/137)6.3 (10/159)-7.6 [-14.49, -0.67]0.03211.3 (2/159)-12.6 [-18.65, -6.57]< 0.0001
Female23.7 (14/59)0.0 (0/38)-23.7 [-34.58, -12.87]0.00074.8 (2/42)-19.0 [-31.59, -6.35]0.0120
Smoking classification
Never smoked22.4 (17/76)1.9 (1/54)-20.5 [-30.55, -10.48]0.00065.0 (3/60)-17.4 [-28.24, -6.50]0.0062
Current smoker20.0 (8/40)6.6 (4/61)-13.4 [-27.31, 0.42]0.05880.0 (0/57)-20.0 [-32.40, -7.60]0.0005
Ex-smoker10.0 (8/80)6.1 (5/82)-3.9 [-12.27, 4.47]0.39981.2 (1/84)-8.8 [-15.78, -1.84]0.0160
Erosive esophagitis grade4
LA Grade A/B11.0 (17/155)3.1 (5/159)-7.8 [-13.44, -2.21]0.00751.3 (2/158)-9.7 [-14.92, -4.48]0.0002
LA Grade C/D39.0 (16/41)13.2 (5/38)-25.9 [-44.26, -7.47]0.01144.7 (2/43)-34.4 [-50.58, -18.17]0.0001
CYP2C19 genotype
Extensive metabolizers19.6 (31/158)5.4 (9/166)-14.2 [-21.28, -7.11]0.00011.8 (3/168)-17.8 [-24.34, -11.33]< 0.0001
Poor metabolizers5.3 (2/38)3.2 (1/31)-2.0 [-11.48, 7.40]1.00003.0 (1/33)-2.2 [-11.43, 6.97]1.0000
H. pylori infection status
Positive3.7 (1/27)2.7 (1/37)-1.0 [-9.84, 7.83]1.00000.0 (0/27)-3.7 [-10.83, 3.42]1.0000
Negative18.9 (32/169)5.6 (9/160)-13.3 [-20.21, -6.41]0.00032.2 (4/179)-16.7 [-22.99. -10.41]< 0.0001
Table 4 Summary of treatment-emergent adverse events during maintenance treatment n (%)
LPZ 15 mg (n = 201)
VPZ 10 mg (n = 202)
VPZ 20 mg (n = 204)
EventsPatientsEventsPatientsEventsPatients
Any TEAE166103 (51.2)220109 (54.0)212120 (58.8)
Drug-related TEAE3023 (11.4)2621 (10.4)2321 (10.3)
TEAE leading to study discontinuation108 (4.0)55 (2.5)88 (3.9)
Any serious TEAE44 (2.0)55 (2.5)44 (2.0)
Death00 (0.0)00 (0.0)00 (0.0)
TEAEs reported in ≥ 2% of patients in any group, irrespective of causal relationship to study medication, during maintenance treatment.
TEAE (preferred term)LPZ 15 mgVPZ 10 mgVPZ 20 mg
Nasopharyngitis28 (13.9)34 (16.8)27 (13.2)
Diarrhea11 (5.5)6 (3.0)5 (2.5)
Upper respiratory tract inflammation3 (1.5)8 (4.0)4 (2.0)
Elevated blood creatinine phosphokinase2 (1.0)4 (2.0)6 (2.9)
Elevated blood triglycerides6 (3.0)1 (0.5)5 (2.5)
Fall1 (0.5)8 (4.0)2 (1.0)
Gastroenteritis1 (0.5)5 (2.5)5 (2.5)
Back pain1 (0.5)3 (1.5)5 (2.5)
Constipation4 (2.0)2 (1.0)3 (1.5)
Elevated ALT11 (0.5)3 (1.5)4 (2.0)
Contusion1 (0.5)5 (2.5)2 (1.0)
Seasonal allergy2 (1.0)4 (2.0)2 (1.0)
Bronchitis2 (1.0)5 (2.5)0 (0.0)
Dizziness1 (0.5)4 (2.0)2 (1.0)
Abnormal liver function test21 (0.5)2 (1.0)4 (2.0)
Abnormal hepatic function21 (0.5)0 (0.0)4 (2.0)
Periodontitis0 (0.0)4 (2.0)1 (0.5)
Table 5 Histopathology of gastric mucosa: neuroendocrine cell density (/mm2)
LPZ 15 mg
VPZ 10 mg
VPZ 20 mg
nMean (SD)nMean (SD)nMean (SD)
Epithelial cells (× 103)
Baseline281.58 (0.4831)291.82 (0.3188)281.74 (0.3943)
Week 24241.63 (0.2689)261.71 (0.4304)281.54 (0.4744)
Grimelius-positive cells (× 102)
Baseline280.716 (0.3997)290.705 (0.5562)280.656 (0.3778)
Week 24241.06 (0.2676)261.07 (0.3858)280.943 (0.4260)
Chromogranin A-positive cells (× 102)
Baseline281.35 (0.6625)291.25 (0.7250)281.35 (0.7073)
Week 24241.35 (0.2962)261.31 (0.4595)281.20 (0.5041)
Synaptophysin-positive cells (× 102)
Baseline281.73 (0.7005)291.73 (0.8123)281.83 (0.9076)
Week 24241.58 (0.3716)261.55 (0.4490)281.45 (0.6173)
Ki-67-positive cells (× 102)
Baseline281.44 (0.8192)291.10 (0.6624)281.32 (0.5513)
Week 24241.14 (0.5037)261.09 (0.4075)281.05 (0.4853)