Surgical management of polycystic liver disease

Table 1 Open and Laparoscopic fenestration for polycystic liver disease

Reference	No. of patients	Technique (n)	Mortality (%)	Morbidity (%)	Mean follow-up(mo)	Rate of symptomrecurrence (%)	Re-operation(%)
Lin[40]	3	Open	0	0	32	0	0
Van Erpecum[21]	9	Open	1 (11)	0	48	0	0
Turnage[47]	5	Open	1 (20)	1 (20)	10	40	0
Sanchez[67]	7	Open	0	NR	18	57	0
Farges[68]	13	Open	0	9 (69)	84	23	0
Gigot[25]	10	Open (9)	0	6 (60)	73	11	11
		Lap (1)	0	0		0	0
Koperna[41]	39	Open (34)	0	NR	75	21	21
		Lap (5)	0	NR		0	0
Morino[42]	9	Lap (9)	0	4 (44)	NR	40	NR
		Conv. (2)
Kabbej[24]	13	Lap (13)	0	7 (54)	26	72	23
Martin[43]	13	Open (6)	0	2 (33)	96	20	20
		Lap (7)	0	2 (29)	37	71	71
Katkhouda[44]	9	Lap (9)	0	3 (33)	30	11	11
		Conv. (1)
Fiamingo[45]	6	Lap	0	3 (50)	1-671	25	0
Marks[46]	6	Lap	0	4 (67)	2-721	14	0

Lap: Laparoscopic; Conv: Converted from Laparoscopic to Open; NR: Not reported.

¹Follow-up range in months.

Table 2 Hepatic resection with and without fenestration for polycystic liver disease

Author	No. of patients	Technique (n)	Mortality (%)	Morbidity (%)	Mean follow-up (mo)	Rate of symptomrecurrence (%)	Re-operation(%)
Turnage[47]	3	Fen & Res	2 (67)	2 (67)	9.6	33	0
Vauthey[2]	5	Fen & Res	0	5 (100)	14	0	0
Henne-Bruns[48]	8	Fen & Res	0	3 (38)	15	50	0
Que[23]	31	Fen & Res	1 (3)	18 (58)	28	3	0
Soravia[49]	10	Fen & Res	1 (10)	2 (20)	68	33	11
Koperna[41]	5	Fen & Res	0	NR	NR	0	0
Martin[43]	9	Res	0	6 (67)	9	33	0
Vons[50]	12	Res	1 (8)	10 (83)	34	17	0
Hansman[51]	2	Res	0	0	NR	100	0
Yang[52]	7	Fen & Res	0	7 (100)	20	100	0

Fen: Fenestration; Res: Resection; NR: Not reported.

Table 3 Liver Transplantation for polycystic liver disease

Author	No. of patients	Previous surgical procedure	Combined liver/Kidney Tx	Mortality	Mean follow-up (mo)
Kwok[65]	1	1	1	1	-
Starzl[53]	4	0	1	2	26
Uddin[54]	3	0	0	0	NR
Washburn[55]	5	4	1	1	38
Lang[56]	17	6	8	5	12
Swenson[58]	9	4	3	1	26
Pirenne[59]	16	4	1	2	18-1202
Takegoshi[60]	11	0	0	0	8
Koyama[61]	11	0	0	0	18
Gustafsson[63]	7	4	3	0	4
Becker[62]	17	NR	17	3	49
Ueda[64]	31	NR	0	0	32
Kirchner[66]	36	NR	15	5	62

NR: Not reported.

¹Indicates living-donor transplantation,

²Range of follow-up in months.