Systematic Reviews
Copyright ©The Author(s) 2016.
World J Gastrointest Surg. Jan 27, 2016; 8(1): 95-100
Published online Jan 27, 2016. doi: 10.4240/wjgs.v8.i1.95
Table 1 Patient demographics
YearFirst authorNumber of patients
Age (yr)
Gender
Body mass index (kg/m2)
Operative procedure
SILCCLCSILCCLCSILC
CLC
SILCCLCSILC
CLC
MaleFemaleMaleFemaleRightLeftRightLeft
2011Kim SJ731066563----22.725.620262867
2011McNally ME27466773132113212726148358
2011Papaconstantinou HT26266566111111112828194194
2012Curro G1010605943432526100100
2012Egi H101068.568444422.521.9100100
2012Fujii S232363.965.21013101321.622.9914914
2012Huscher CG16167070------88610
2012Lu CC276860.2664.2916361636--8181645
2012Poon JT252567671418141823.323.6817916
2013Kwag SJ244859.55991891824.424024048
2013Mynster T1836707381681624247111422
2013Pedraza R505064.666.32527252727.23133143314
2013Yun JA669361593355335523.8224.23660930
2014Takemasa I15015064.365.57571757121.722.469816981
2014Lim SW4426363.963.8281702817023.723.811151582
Total589970--250463250463--292240366411
Table 2 Postoperative mortality, morbidity, conversion rate and additional port insertion rate n (%)
First authorMortality
Morbidity
Conversion to open procedure
Additional port insertion
SILCCLCSILCCLCSILCCLCSILC
Kim SJ01 (1.37)23 (31.5)39 (36.8)1 (1.36)3 (2.83)-
McNally ME005 (18.5)16 (34.8)06 (13.0)5 (18.5)
Papaconstantinou HT----01 (7.7)3 (11.5)
Curro G002 (20.0)1 (10)00-
Egi H000001 (10)-
Fujii S003 (13.0)5 (21.7)01 (4.35)-
Huscher CG003 (18.8)5 (31.3)001 (6.3)
Lu CC002 (7.4)3 (4.41)---
Poon JT004 (16.0)3 (12)00-
Kwag SJ002 (8.33)4 (8.33)007 (29.2)
Mynster T003 (16.7)6 (16.7)1 (5.56)4 (11.1)3 (16.7)
Pedraza R--7 (14.0)4 (8)01 (4)5 (27.8)
Yun JA006 (9.09)14 (15.1)1 (1.52)5 (5.37)-
Takemasa I0018 (12.0)25 (16.7)2 (1.33)5 (3.33)12 (8.0)
Lim SW007 (15.9)46 (17.5)0010 (22.7)
Total01 (0.11)85 (15.1)171 (18.1)5 (0.89)27 (2.99)46 (13.0)
Table 3 Other short-term clinical outcomes
First authorOperative time (min)
Estimated blood loss (mL)
Length of hospital stay (d)
SILCCLCSILCCLCSILCCLC
Kim SJ2742542824189.615.5
McNally ME114135505035
Papaconstantinou HT14414457873.65
Curro G170160355066
Egi H1922224851.5810.5
Fujii S17417991098.212.7
Huscher CG147129200-67
Lu CC180184355077
Poon JT155124508045
Kwag SJ2512371351447.18.1
Mynster T16718903833
Pedraza R127.9126.764.487.24.54
Yun JA155174--89
Takemasa I17217332378.28.7
Lim SW185139.282.370.18.28.8
Table 4 Oncological outcomes
First authorHarvested LN
Proximal resection margin (cm)
Distal resection margin (cm)
SILCCLCSILCCLCSILCCLC
Kim SJ29.323.233.417.917.213
McNally ME1517----
Papaconstantinou HT18179.39.310.59.3
Curro G2524----
Egi H1516.5----
Fujii S19.923.38.88.59.57.6
Huscher CG1816--86
Lu CC----76
Poon JT1620885.56
Kwag SJ19.620.811.211.47.59.2
Mynster T1720----
Pedraza R21.419.2----
Yun JA242714.41516.615.8
Takemasa I22.222.4----
Lim SW23.227.410.511.26.65.5