Copyright
©The Author(s) 2015.
World J Diabetes. Nov 25, 2015; 6(16): 1312-1322
Published online Nov 25, 2015. doi: 10.4239/wjd.v6.i16.1312
Published online Nov 25, 2015. doi: 10.4239/wjd.v6.i16.1312
Table 1 Care parameters for basic treatment of uncomplicated diabetes and for the treatment of chronic and acute complications
| Medical conditions | Care component | Guidelines |
| Uncomplicated diabetes | ||
| Consultation of diabetes specialist or a general practitioner | 4/yr | |
| Fasting glucose test | 4/yr | |
| Urine glucose test | 6/yr | |
| Glycated hemoglobin | 2/yr | |
| Proteinuria test | 1/yr | |
| Blood lipid test TG, HDL-cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol | 1/yr | |
| Electrocardiogram | 1/yr | |
| Chest X-ray | 1/yr | |
| Ophthalmology consult | 1/yr | |
| Oral hypoglycemic agents | ||
| Glibenclamide 5 mg OR in combination with metformin | 3 tablets/d | |
| Metformin® 500 mg | 3 tablets/d | |
| Glucophage® 850 mg OR in combination with Amarel® | 3 tablets/d | |
| Amarel® 4 mg | 1 tablet/d | |
| For insulin users | ||
| Syringes | 1/wk (min)-1/d (max) | |
| Insulin | 30 UI (min) et 60 UI (max)/d | |
| Strips for blood glucose control | 1 strip/d (min) | |
| 3 strips/d (max) | ||
| Glucometer | 1 (Duration: 2 yr) | |
| Chronic complications | ||
| Proliferative retinopathy | ||
| Consultation in ophthalmology | 3/yr | |
| Retinography | 1/yr | |
| Laser photocoagulation | 1/yr | |
| Overt nephropathy | ||
| Consultation in nephrology | 2/yr | |
| Blood creatinine test | 2/yr | |
| Serum protein test | 2/yr | |
| Serum electrolytes test (sodium, potassium) | 2/yr | |
| Urinary electrolytes test (sodium, potassium) | 2/yr | |
| Urine creatinine test | 2/yr | |
| Proteinuria | 2/yr | |
| Hemogram | 2/yr | |
| Urine bacteriology | 4/yr | |
| Urine culture (ECBU) | 1/yr | |
| Antiplatelet drugs | ||
| Aspirin® 100 mg OR | 1 tablet/d | |
| Plavix® 75 mg | 1 tablet/d | |
| Antihypertensive (ARA2) | ||
| Valsartan® 80 mg | 1 tablet/d | |
| Diuretics: | ||
| Laxilix® 40 mg OR | 3 tablets/d | |
| Laxilix® special 500 mg | Half tablet/d | |
| Calcium carbonate (added to antiplatelet therapy, maximum cost) | 2 tablets/d | |
| Statin (added to antiplatelet therapy, maximum cost) | 1 tablet/d | |
| Renal failure | ||
| Dialysis | 2 session/wk | |
| Potex® 4000 UI (EPO) | 50 UI/kg weight (max) | |
| 2 sessions/wk | ||
| Calcium carbonate 500 mg | 1.5 g or 3 tablets/d (max) | |
| Ischemic heart disease | ||
| Consultation in cardiology | 2/an | |
| Antiplatelet drugs | See under nephropathy | |
| Statins | ||
| Simvastatin (Zocor®) OR | 1 tablet/d | |
| Atorvastatin (Tahor®) | 1 tablet/d | |
| Exercise electrocardiogram testing | 1/yr | |
| Echo doppler | 1/yr | |
| Cardiac ultrasound | 1/yr | |
| Coronarography | 1/yr | |
| Hypertension | ||
| Consultation in cardiology | 1/yr | |
| Antihypertensive drugs (ACEI) | ||
| Captopril® 25 mg OU | 3 tablets/d | |
| Ramipril® 5 mg | 1 tablet/d | |
| Diuretics | See under nephropathy | |
| Aggregation inhibitors | See under nephropathy | |
| Semi quantitative urine protein test | 2/yr | |
| Blood creatinine test | 2/yr | |
| Proteinemia | 2/yr | |
| Blood electrolytes test (Na, K, Ca) | 2/an | |
| Stroke (chronic phase) | ||
| Consultation in cardiology | 2/yr | |
| Antiplatelet drugs | See under nephropathy | |
| Diabetic foot | ||
| Consultation in podiatry | 1/yr | |
| Arteriography of the lower limbs | 1/yr | |
| Physiotherapy sessions | 10-20 sessions/yr | |
| Echo doppler | 1/yr | |
| Statins | See under ischemic heart disease | |
| Antiplatelet drugs | 1 tablet/d | |
| Orthopedic shoes | 2 pairs/yr | |
| Acute complications | ||
| Ketoacidosis | ||
| Hospitalization | 7 d | |
| Blood glucose test | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Glycated hemoglobin | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Hemogram | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Blood lipids test | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Blood electrolytes test (Na, K) | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Blood creatinine test | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Blood urea test | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Electrocardiogram | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Chest X- ray | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Echo doppler | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Keto-Diastix® box of 50 strips (blood biology) | 3 times/d for 3 d | |
| Perfusion | 3 d | |
| Diabetic foot (acute) | ||
| Hospitalization | 90 d | |
| Antibiotics | ||
| Oxaciline® 500 mg | 4 tablets/d | |
| 3 wk of treatment without bone involvement (min); 10 wk when bone involved (max) | ||
| Vasodilator: Vastarel® 35 mg | 2 tablets/d, 22 wk | |
| Biopsy | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Antibiogram | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Bone radiography | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Vascular ultrasound | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Dressings | 1/wk, 22 wk | |
| Foot surgery | ||
| Minor surgery (56%) | ||
| Major surgery, amputation (44%) | ||
| Prosthesis | ||
| End stage renal disease | ||
| Hospitalization | 30 d | |
| Ultrasound | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Electrolytes blood test (Na, K) | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Creatinine blood test | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Proteinemia | Done once during hospitalization | |
| Stroke | ||
| Hospitalization | 18 d | |
| Vasodilatator: Vastarel® 35 mg | 2 tablets/d, 18 d | |
| Anticoagulants | 1 tablet/d, 18 d | |
| Rehabilitation/physical therapy | 18 d | |
Table 2 Medical costs per individual per year for uncomplicated diabetes and for complications (in United States dollars) in the four countries
| Medical condition | Bénin | Burkina Faso | Guinea | Mali | ||||||||||||
| Public sector | Private sector | Public sector | Private sector | Public sector | Private sector | Public sector | Private sector | |||||||||
| Min | Max | Min | Max | Min | Max | Min | Max | Min | Max | Min | Max | Min | Max | Min | Max | |
| Uncomplicated diabetes | 212 | 542 | 310 | 828 | 224 | 451 | 363 | 859 | 126 | 422 | 437 | 1093 | 137 | 335 | 390 | 869 |
| Chronic complications - Basic medical cost for uncomplicated diabetes plus additional annual cost for single complication | ||||||||||||||||
| Retinopathy | 320 | 686 | 421 | 987 | 306 | 532 | 465 | 984 | 187 | 488 | 511 | 1243 | 177 | 374 | 524 | 1002 |
| Stroke | 233 | 576 | 672 | 1360 | 241 | 469 | 1644 | 2155 | 135 | 432 | 1267 | 1937 | 147 | 345 | 687 | 1850 |
| Nephropathy | 850 | 1920 | 1614 | 3198 | 783 | 1299 | 2578 | 3412 | 808 | 1578 | 2366 | 4256 | 491 | 1808 | 1516 | 4069 |
| Hypertension | 345 | 751 | 1256 | 2065 | 377 | 605 | 2074 | 2590 | 367 | 667 | 1784 | 2655 | 293 | 556 | 1212 | 2408 |
| Ischemic heart disease | 535 | 1297 | 1050 | 2188 | 496 | 785 | 1943 | 2577 | 313 | 612 | 1484 | 2553 | 441 | 1324 | 1002 | 2881 |
| Diabetic foot | 694 | 1533 | 1103 | 2386 | 923 | 1337 | 2447 | 4294 | 527 | 877 | 1717 | 3393 | 484 | 1424 | 1043 | 3172 |
| Acute complications - Basic annual medical cost for uncomplicated diabetes plus additional cost per episode of acute complication | ||||||||||||||||
| Keto acidosis | 406 | 802 | 576 | 1297 | 387 | 665 | 1036 | 1936 | 222 | 531 | 726 | 1758 | 243 | 463 | 606 | 1391 |
| Infected diabetic foot requiring hospitalization | 728 | 1539 | 1020 | 3860 | 729 | 1702 | 6886 | 12043 | 667 | 1129 | 2897 | 6679 | 698 | 1340 | 1709 | 5802 |
| Stroke (acute phase) | 637 | 1117 | 834 | 1935 | 576 | 1064 | 2316 | 4147 | 510 | 933 | 1427 | 3315 | 455 | 705 | 1003 | 2266 |
Table 3 Diabetes medical costs and national income in the study countries (United States dollars)
| Countries | Mali | Benin | Burkina Faso | Guinea | |
| GNI per capita (2013) | 670 | 790 | 670 | 460 | |
| % of population with < $2/d (= $730/yr) | 78.7 | 74.3 | 72.6 | 72.7 | |
| Uncomplicated diabetes | |||||
| Minimum cost | 137.21 | 211.63 | 224.42 | 125.58 | |
| Maximum cost | 868.60 | 827.91 | 859.30 | 1093.02 | |
| % of GNI (% of poverty threshold1) | |||||
| Minimum | 20.5 (18.7) | 26.8 (28.9) | 33.5 (30.7) | 27.3 (17.2) | |
| Maximum | 129.6 (118.9) | 104.8 (113.4) | 128.3 (117.6) | 237.6 (149.7) | |
| Diabetes + retinopathy | |||||
| Minimum cost | 176.74 | 320.93 | 305.81 | 187.21 | |
| Maximum cost | 1002.33 | 987.21 | 983.84 | 1243.02 | |
| % of GNI (% of poverty threshold) | |||||
| Minimum | 26.4 (24.2) | 40.6 (43.9) | 45.6 (41.9) | 46.8 (25.6) | |
| Maximum | 149.6 (137.3) | 125.0 (135.2) | 141.6 (134.7) | 270.2 (170.3) | |
| Diabetes + nephropathy | |||||
| Minimum cost | 490.70 | 850.00 | 782.56 | 808.14 | |
| Maximum cost | 4068.60 | 3197.67 | 3411.63 | 4256.98 | |
| % of GNI (% of poverty threshold) | |||||
| Minimum | 73.2 (67.2) | 107.6 (116.4) | 116.8 (107.2) | 175.7 (110.7) | |
| Maximum | 607.3 (557.3) | 404.8 (438.0) | 509.2 (467.3) | 925.4 (583.1) | |
- Citation: Alouki K, Delisle H, Besançon S, Baldé N, Sidibé-Traoré A, Drabo J, Djrolo F, Mbanya JC, Halimi S. Simple calculator to estimate the medical cost of diabetes in sub-Saharan Africa. World J Diabetes 2015; 6(16): 1312-1322
- URL: https://www.wjgnet.com/1948-9358/full/v6/i16/1312.htm
- DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.4239/wjd.v6.i16.1312
